ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Immigration Daily


Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network




Connect to us

Make us Homepage



The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
© 1995-
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Angelo Paparelli on Dysfunctional Government

U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment

Rate this Entry

Since January 25, the events in Cairo's Tahrir (Liberation) Square have transfixed the world.  Following on the heels of the Tunisian people's overthrow of their despot, the Egyptian uprising reveals a fundamental law of physics: In a closed system, energy can be neither created nor destroyed. 

So too in politics.  Universal political energy -- the pent-up longing for freedom and self-determination -- is now leveraged and magnified in new and unpredictable ways by Twitter and Facebook. Inexorably, that energy, as the Egyptian protestors have shown us, will ultimately be released. 

Hosni Mubarak's 30-year authoritarian, pressure-cooker reign, supported throughout by the unmonitored and unaccountable Egyptian police, is coming to an end. And once again, as many times before, the American government and political establishment have been caught flat-footed, on the wrong side of history, knocked over by popular energy, while supporting a fallen dictator.

 A similar dynamic is playing out inside America.  The tightening of the border by "deploying historic levels of manpower, resources and technology and increasing collaboration with federal, state, local and tribal, and Mexican partners" has achieved unprecedented levels of impregnability -- according to Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano in remarks at the University of Texas in El Paso last week.  America is rapidly becoming a closed system. 

At the same time, the energy-pressure readings -- of Latinos, Asians and other immigrant groups who rightly perceive themselves as targets of xenophobia -- are escalating.  As reported by the nonpartisan Migration Policy Institute and the Government Accountability Office, the immigration enforcers, in league with state, regional and city police agencies operating under the Congressionally authorized 287(g) program, are largely unmonitored and unaccountable.  The 287(g) program, touted as a means of apprehending and removing dangerous foreign felons, has instead gone "rogue" and mostly netted petty immigration violators and small-scale misdemeanants, while arousing ire and fear in local immigrant communities

As the energy of righteous anger builds, not only traditional Democrats but even conservative Latinos chide President Obama for abandoning his campaign promises, and failing to try hard, let alone deliver, on immigration reform. The Republicans (notwithstanding Norm Coleman's recent rebuke of Tom Tancredo) are even more adrift on immigration, mounting a campaign against "anchor babies" and trying to override the 14th amendment's guarantee of birthright citizenship.

Meantime, despite a virulent economic recession and a record number of deportations, the unauthorized immigrant population (11.2 million in 2010) remains virtually unchanged from the year before, according to the Pew Hispanic Center

All of the essential requirements for an energized reaction are present. DREAMers have nowhere to go but to the street and to their smartphones.  Spanish- and other foreign-language media will report growing resentment, anger and the desire for justice among their U.S. citizen and immigrant readers  -- reporting largely unnoticed in the Anglo mediascape.  U.S. politicians of every stripe, like Hosni Mubarak, will be caught unawares when the energy is released. 

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was correct:  "The world is full of obvious things which nobody by any chance ever observes."  To politicos of the left and right, the only proper response is, "Duh!" 

Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to Facebook Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to Twitter Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to Google Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to StumbleUpon Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to Reddit Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to Digg Submit "U.S. Immigration's Egyptian Moment" to

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


  1. Don Miller's Avatar
    Mr. Paparelli is, as usual, completely obfuscating the issue and his intent is obvious. This is NOT an issue of "latinos" or Asians, it is an issue of Mexicans (and some Central Americans)carrying out a sort of "volkswanderung", or tribal migration, or invasion...reader's choice here, across our border into our country. No one is opposed in this controversy to Puertorricans, Cubans, Uruguayans, Chileans,et al., all of whom are "latinos". I am not aware of any concern on either side over Chinese, Japanese, or other Asian immigrants. This is strictly an issue involving Mexico and Mexicans and the constant and inflammatory use of the terms "latinos" and "hispanics" by such as Mr. Paparelly is deliberately intended to unnecessarily provoke immigrants and residents from other Latin American countries who are not at all involved in this controversy. All readers and concerned Americans should pick up on this pro-immigrant propaganda usage from the lawyers and call them out when they employ it.
  2. Angelo Paparelli's Avatar
    Mr. Miller:

    Thank you for your email. I question your position of authority to speak for the other-than-Mexican groups you name. Certainly, many persons of color (not limited merely to persons of Mexican origin) have publicly expressed their concern over Arizona's SB1070 and over the 287(g) program because of the fears of racial profiling that these unstructured and largely unaccountable programs have engendered. I also question your statement that the other-than-Mexican groups "are not at all involved in this controversy." They are clearly part of the pressure-cooker situation that I described in my blog posting.

    Further, your use of such electrically-charged terms as "tribal migration, or invasion" is an example of the pot calling the kettle black -- at least that is what Native Americans would likely say to describe the arrival of the first European settlers. It seems you missed the point of my post, namely, that our politicians are clueless and at some point sooner or later, just like with the Egyptian popular uprising, the energy that is building will be released. I just hope we have the safety valves in place (read this to mean fair and humane laws that reflect our values) in order to keep the transition peaceful and in America's tradition as a nation of immigrants.
  3. Daniel G. DeGriselles's Avatar
    Well put. May I have your position to circulate this? A lot? Dan DeGriselles, public defender's office, San Bernardino County
  4. Daniel G. DeGriselles's Avatar
    Make that "permission."
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: