ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Immigration Daily


Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network




Connect to us

Make us Homepage



The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
© 1995-
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Angelo Paparelli on Dysfunctional Government

Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid

Rate this Entry

The Office of Ombudsman (Ombudsman) to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has just released an outstanding 2009 Annual Report to Congress.    The culmination of an especially ambitious and successful year of several spot-on recommendations, the Report focuses a laser beam on the many shortfalls in USCIS's performance. 

Among the Report's many worthy insights, the Ombudsman cites numerous customer-service lapses:

  • USCIS has been forced to fund day-to-day operations through the ebb and flow of filing fees rather than by Congressionally appropriated sums (this includes the $491 million dollar contract with IBM now funded solely by Premium Processing fees to pay for the agency's electronic "Transformation" initiatives which will not begin to bear fruit until February, 2011 and may yet "incur substantial additional costs").  

  • USCIS has not moved to enable the scanning of paper documents or the online payment of filing fees.

  • USCIS has endorsed the National Customer Service Center (NCSC) adoption of a call-center scripting approach that relies on canned and unhelpful responses (Tier 1) and a rotating crew of USCIS Information Officers who lack access to agency records (Tier 2) to address egregious delays and deficiencies in USCIS's performance.

  • USCIS has not met its self-imposed targets for reductions in average processing times for all categories of petitions and applications for immigration benefits.

The work of the Ombudsman is a godsend, but not a deus ex machina.  With altogether too much toleration and not enough outrage for my taste, the Ombudsman's report restates longstanding USCIS problems but does not condemn the lack of significant forward movement.  Why doesn't the Report seriously challenge: 

  • The flawed premises and exaggerated conclusions of the agency's H-1B fraud and abuse survey? 

  • The fact that the second-largest category of new hires involved "fraud and security positions" during the first stage of expanded USCIS hiring" funded by user fees that should be earmarked for adjudication? 

  • The manifest lack of accountability of adjudicators who flout policy memoranda issued by USCIS? or 

  • The USCIS assertion of legitimacy and reasonableness that the precious right of employment authorization shoul ordinarily take 90 days to grant?

  • The lack of meaningful appeal rights and right to legal counsel for all parties in interest (including the foreign citizen applicants) in all categories of immigration-benefits requests? 

According to a knowledgeable Congressional insider who was present at its creation, the Office of Ombudsman -- beyond its stated statutory mission of "assist[ing] individuals and employers in resolving problems" with USCIS -- was intended to take the burden of immigration-related constituent services off the backs of the Senators' and Representatives' staffs. The problem with offloading constituent complaints to the Ombudsman is that it takes pressure off Congress to hold USCIS accountable. Why hold an oversight committee hearing (Members of Congress might say candidly to their visages in the mirror) when we can read and forget each annual Ombudsman's report?

The time for tolerance is past due.  Righteous indignation is needed now.  Congress must bite the bullet and fund USCIS on a long-term basis with appropriated funds. It should also expand the Ombudsman's authority so that it is "Tri-Bureau" in scope, and covers all three agencies (USCIS, ICE and CBP) that together interpret and apply the immigration laws within Homeland Security. Indeed, if the Obama Administration and Congress are serious about the proper functioning of the federal immigration system, they would also create Offices of the Ombudsman for the Departments of Labor and State, and place a "Tri-Department" Ombudsman on top, so that stakeholders really have a "seat at the table" for comprehensive immigration reform.

Meantime, the USCIS Ombudsman should stop sipping the agency's Kool-Aid. It should conduct a full financial audit of USCIS's application of user fees for purposes within and outside of the adjudication-only mandate of the Homeland Security Act.  It should be directly involved in all aspects of the Transformation program, including contract administration.  It should abide by Immigration and Nationality Act § 452 which confers on the Ombudsman "the responsibility and authority . . . to appoint local ombudsmen and make available at least 1 such ombudsman for each State [emphasis added]." 

Don't get me wrong.  The Ombudsman is performing well a critically important role.  But there is simply too much dysfunction in America's broken immigration system merely to compliment the Ombudsman for a solid, if temperate, report.  

The heavy lifting on comprehensive immigration reform involves far more than merely enhanced border protection, a path to legal status for the undocumented and an orderly system for future worker flows.  It will require a complete overhaul of the government agencies that now mismanage a slew of immigration programs that, if optimally administered, could and should be the rejuvenating lifeblood of our nation.

Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to Facebook Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to Twitter Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to Google Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to StumbleUpon Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to Reddit Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to Digg Submit "Trying Not to Sip the Immigration Kool-Aid" to

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


  1. jgo's Avatar
    Nanny state?!? The visa system is so lax that US government refuses even to run proper background investigations on visa applicants.
  2. Coach Hobo Handbags's Avatar
    *This winter, see if you can hear how the season transforms sound, as well as the scenery.
  3. Maya McGillivray's Avatar
    The themes and arguments of the students are coined and implemented. It is instilled for the smoothness of the activities of blogs and offered for the viewers. The essay services reviews are very important and essential.
  4. bryce knorr's Avatar

    I was just passing and i decided to drop this information for those who need it. If you are looking for a loan or a legitimate project funding company to finance your project or you wish to start a new business venture in 2016 but do not have enough funds, here is how i was able to get a company loan just few weeks back.
    After being scammed several times by loan some hungry scams. I decided to give up and meet a friend of my to ask him for funds as i have also been turned down by my bank several times. He told me he is doing business with a loan he took from an international Islamic credit union. So he directed me to take loan from them too. Initially i didn't believe him because of my previous bad experience with some online lending company pretending to be lenders. But he convinced me to try once more and see the difference. Because i am a Muslim, i hold on to my faith and decided to try one last time because i believe since it is a Muslim loan union, we are always truthful. When i tried, i was surprise that after 3 days working days, i got a loan of Rp500.000.000.00 from them. The whole process was simple. All their staffs are people who have the fear of Allah in their heart. No hidden charges. No collateral was required from me. I am so happy now and my business is moving on well. I want to advice anyone who is urgently looking for a genuine place to get a soft loan to contact them. I will not give out all their information's here for fear of impersonation. I will only provide their email: ( ) I just decided to drop this piece of information so you won't fall into the hands of scam when looking for where to get a legitimate loan online to start business or do other things in 2016. Contact them now and experience financial freedom in 2016.....
  5. dfgistedfd's Avatar
    Blogs and entries of the data for the finesse and perfection is entailed. It is implemented and advanced with the bright and exact conceptions of how they can write my essay. It is the route of the success of the citizens. It is oriental and advanced. It is the skilled and acknowledge. It is the mentioned and determined fact.
  6. ZUNNA23's Avatar

    My name is zunna, I am from New york, United State, am here to testify of how i got my loan from Mrs Ingrid {} after i applied Two times from various loan lenders who claimed to be lenders right in this forum,i thought their lending where real and i applied but they never gave me loan. I was in need of an urgent loan to start a business and i applied from various loan lenders who promised to help but they never gave me the loan.Until a friend of mine introduce me to Mrs Ingrid kloet the C.E.O of INGRID Loan Company who promised to help me with a loan of my desire and he really did as he promised without any form of delay, I never thought there are still reliable loan lenders until i met Mrs Ingrid, who really helped me with my loan and changed my life for better. I dont know if you are in need of an urgent loan, free feel to contact Ingrid loan company on email{} for help
  7. Mike Robert's Avatar
    Hello applicant

    My name is Mr. Mike Robert, and i am the owner of the firm known as Mike Robert Loan Firm. I just want to let you all know that i give out loans from 5,000.00 USD to a maximum amount of 10,000,000.00 USD with a low interest rate of 3% and no upfront payments involved.

    Our loan duration ranges from a minimum of 1 year to a maximum of 30 years depending on the amount needed and we work 24 hours apart from Sunday's and make sure that we do everything according to the clients satisfaction, we all we can to help those that are able to meet with the requirement's of our company.

    I give you all a 100% that you will get this loan after you apply for it because we won?t scam you, we are Christians, so scamming of our fellow humans is against my believes and it is stated that whom so ever that cheats his or her follow man shall be cast down to hell for all eternity and we will never subject ourselves to such a fate for just little money.

    Contact us today through our company emails address so that the loan processing will start as soon as possible.

    Email :

    Mr. Mike Robert
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: