ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Immigration Daily


Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network




Connect to us

Make us Homepage



The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
© 1995-
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Angelo Paparelli on Dysfunctional Government

Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles

Rating: 4 votes, 5.00 average.

The most quotable of British Prime Ministers could well have been talking about the American immigration system rather than describing Russia in 1939. U.S. immigration law is like stratified rock, revealing layer on layer of Congressional accretions laid down over many years, with the superstructure upended in tectonic shifts triggered by the baffling and contradictory interpretations of multiple agencies and courts. Not surprisingly, Thomas Stanley in The Millionaire Next Door recommended immigration law as a career, predicting that many foreign citizens, whether affluent or less so, would find America an attractive destination and need a chaperone to guide them through the maze of red tape.

If Congress ever grows enough of a spine to tackle comprehensive immigration reform, it must do more than merely resolve the big items -- border and interior enforcement; legalization of unauthorized migrants already here; and a plan for future flows of sojourners and permanent residents. It must also strive to simplify the law.

Consider what should be a straightforward concept -- following the rules. How does a noncitizen comply with the immigration laws? What does it take to maintain legal immigration status? Sadly, the answer is as clear as fracking fluid runoff.

For example, without any malevolent intent or affirmative act of misconduct, a temporary entrant (a "nonimmigrant") through the action of a third party, say a parent or spouse, a spouse's employer, a university official, or a lawyer, can "fail to maintain nonimmigrant status," be in a condition known as "unlawful presence" and "not [be] in a lawful nonimmigrant status" -- three phrases in law or regulation that often don't mean the same thing. Thus, a hapless individual may be seen by the authorities as having violated legal status but not be unlawfully present. This could occur, as one example among many, where the person is the spouse of a J-1 exchange visitor who is working under a form of employment permission known as curricular practical training, and the J-1 worker is fired. (This outcome would arise because unlawful presence only occurs if one overstays the period of status authorized, and an exchange visitor, like an academic or vocational student, is admitted for "duration of status," a condition that carries no date-certain expiration. Go figure.)

Or, a foreign citizen can depart the U.S. holding a government certificate allowing permission to return (known as "advance parole") and then reenter in order to await the grant of a green card under the adjustment of status process. Such a person would not have maintained nonimmigrant status -- indeed would not have any legal status (because parole is not a status) -- and yet would not have violated the immigration law. In essence, he or she would be in a non-status as an applicant under color of law awaiting the grant of a pending benefit.

Or, consider a foreign person with a U.S. work permit. As I've noted in an earlier post about human levitation, you may have the right to work here but not to be here.

Or, you might have successfully changed or extended your work-visa status for one, two or three years and received from the immigration authorities an official approval notice with a clip-out status permit (the Form I-94) bearing a validity period, leave the country for a trip to see Grandma, and be readmitted with a new I-94 for a significantly shorter period. This occurs because one component of the Homeland Security Department, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), limits the I-94 to the expiration date of one's passport, while another DHS component, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), ignores the validity period of the passport, and holds that as a condition of maintaining nonimmigrant status you must always make sure your passport is unexpired.

Often, the CBP inspector at the port of entry says nothing about having short-changed the expiration date on the I-94; hence, the entrant may not realize his/her status document has been unduly shortened. The too-frequent result: An unwitting overstay occurs, thereby triggering unlawful presence. And even if the shortening of the status period is noted, the individual could reasonably believe that the longer of the two I-94s (in this case, the clip-out version) prevails over the shorter expiration period. Or s/he may be misled by the DMV who issues a driver's license with a validity period extending to the end date on the clip-out I-94.

Whether or not the person is confused or misled, a USCIS adjudicator, a consular official abroad, a CBP inspector, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer or an immigration judge, when examining the person's immigration compliance history on some future date, may well deny an immigration benefit, refuse a visa, prevent entry or order removal -- all because of confusion over the simple concept of maintaining legal immigration status.

If that's not complicated enough, the legacy agency, the Immigration and Naturalization Service, repeatedly floated a notion (not a published regulation) known misleadingly as the "last action rule" in order to reconcile discrepancies in ending dates on two or more I-94 status documents. The "rule" sounds simple enough: Whichever status was the last one granted ("the last action") controls the person's nonimmigrant status. Except, however, where the last action granted was based on a change rather than an extension of status, then the last action rule is inapplicable. For the stew that is the last action rule, see these confusing links: Bednarz letter, Cook Memo (and referenced Simmons letter), Hernandez letter, and unapproved AILA/INS October 17, 2001 liaison meeting minutes (Item II).

Still worse, if the immigration laws make it virtually impossible to know who's in legal status, they make it harder than a Rubik's Cube to figure out who's here illegally, as DREAM activist Prerna Lal explains in "It's More Complicated than Legal vs. Illegal," her open letter to Ruben Navarette -- which challenges his defense of the slur, "illegal immigrant."

If my effort to explain the mumbo-jumbo of immigration violations and last actions remains confusing, I ask your pardon. Be heartened, however, that errors of these types can be fixed -- assuming that the immigration agency exercises its heart (which it occasionally does). Still, it's a shame USCIS doesn't heed its stakeholders by expanding the areas of forgivable infractions and Congress does not write intelligible immigration laws for law-abiding individuals to follow, a code unlike the current immigration statutes that "yield up meaning only grudgingly" to reveal "morsels of comprehension [which] must be pried from mollusks of jargon."

Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to Facebook Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to Twitter Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to Google Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to StumbleUpon Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to Reddit Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to Digg Submit "Immigration Good Behavior - A Riddle Riddled With Riddles" to

Updated 07-16-2013 at 03:22 PM by APaparelli

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
  1. Anita@jamaicanproverbs's Avatar
    It is a confusing system and one that has a bit of irony in ti when you look at the overall history of the country.

    If only Native Americans had been equipped with the finances and weaponry to establish their own immigration system. It would have solved a lot of problems, right?
  2. Bisolta's Avatar
    Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read, I really appreciate sharing this great post. Keep up your essay writers work.
  3. pioneerseo's Avatar
    If you’re looking for high quality and personal service, you’ve come to the right place. At Oasis Lawn Service we’ll give you the attention and personal service you’ll come to expect and enjoy. Let us put our 25+ years of experience to work for you.
  4. pioneerseo's Avatar
    Excellent Content it its really useful and impressive keep us published with new up-dates. its was really useful.
  5. pioneerseo's Avatar
    We provide education and training to industrial agencies oil and gas, aviation Human resource, NGOs, Government agencies, disaster relief agencies, Domestic and violence centers humanitarian, hospitals, nonprofits, government, law enforcement and emergency relief services and educational
  6. pioneerseo's Avatar
    [COLOR=#000000][FONT=Times New Roman]It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.Visit our website at [/FONT][/COLOR]en las noticias
  7. pioneerseo's Avatar
    [COLOR=#333333][FONT=Tahoma]Keep up the good work. This article might have some more good information on this same topic. I didn't read it till now. But one of my friends recommended me.[/FONT][/COLOR]diabetes destroyer book
  8. pioneerseo's Avatar
    He first launched version 1.0 a few years back, then google sniper 2.0 (as of today, September 2015, it’s version 3.0), leveraging the Warrior Forum to create testimonials and build gsniper reviews
  9. pioneerseo's Avatar
    I read this article. I think You put a lot of effort to create this article. I appreciate your work.[TABLE="width: 215"]
    [TD="width: 215"]myfatdiminisher reviews[/TD]
  10. pioneerseo's Avatar
    Genuinely solid article. It seems like you've put a lot of thought into this and come with a viabel idea. The funny thing was that I used to be thinking about this right before stumbling on to your die F?hrungs
  11. pioneerseo's Avatar
    [COLOR=#000000][FONT=arial]Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here.[/FONT][/COLOR]best pregnancy pillow
  12. pioneerseo's Avatar
    [COLOR=#333333][FONT=Georgia]We have decided to push ourselves forward as an online magazine. Hence we have a new domain and site to focus on this aspect of [/FONT][/COLOR]tuning cars
  13. pioneerseo's Avatar
    Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.fcra
  14. pioneerseo's Avatar
    [COLOR=#990000][FONT=Verdana]Amazing leaves the skin silky smooth and refreshed really seems to last 48 hours. [/FONT][/COLOR]fashion
  15. pioneerseo's Avatar
    [COLOR=#000000][FONT=Times New Roman]I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well.[/FONT][/COLOR]United Nations
  16. pioneerseo's Avatar
    Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here.garotas de programa ribeirao preto
  17. SabrinaGreen's Avatar
    Good behavior makes your personality more grooming and provides you self satisfaction.
  18. brookehiggins007's Avatar
    A riddle riddled with riddles: what a fine term it is.
  19. pioneerseo's Avatar
    Seattle Web Design Company Services Designer Looking to get your website to the top of Yahoo Bing & Google. You Have Found The Best Seo Services and Web Designer in Town. Our Website Design Company We Will Get Your Business to the Top and on Page 1 for each term you want in search engines. Every and any term of our results are guaranteed feel free to contact us 1(509)910-7727. or Email at [email][/email]
  20. MayaAlex's Avatar
    The better idea is to resolve all the confusions and provide the people better alternatives
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: