ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Immigration Daily


Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network




Connect to us

Make us Homepage



Immigration Daily

Chinese Immig. Daily

The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Jason Dzubow on Political Asylum

When Asylees Return Home

Rate this Entry

In the old days, when a person immigrated to the United States, he
would probably never return home or see his family again.* For example,
when my Great-Grandfather David came to the U.S. from Russia in 1904, he
left behind his parents and six siblings.* He never saw them again, and
as far as we know, they and their families died in the Holocaust.*

Today, it's a different story.* It's much easier to remain in contact
with the homeland and to return for a visit.* However, for people who
have received asylum in the United States, return to the home country
may result in the termination of their status.*See*INA 208(c)(2).

Sorry, asylees. Missing grandma's cooking is probably not a valid excuse for returning to your home country.

Despite the possibility of termination, my clients who have received
asylum sometimes need to return home.* There are different reasons for
this-some want to visit sick relatives or help relatives who are in
trouble.* Others are political activists or journalists, and they want
to return home to continue their activities.* A few of my clients from
Afghanistan wanted to return to their country as interpreters with the
U.S. military.*

In cases like these, I explain the legal consequences of returning to
the home country so that the client can weigh the risk of losing asylum
status against her desire to go home.

The provision for termination of asylum, *INA 208(c)(2), states:

Asylum... does not convey a right to remain
permanently in the United States, and may be terminated if the Attorney
General determines that... the alien has voluntarily availed himself or
herself of the protection of the alien's country of nationality.

It's clear from this provision that the AG does not have to terminate asylum if the alien returns to her country ("Asylum... may
be terminated").* Also, return to the country in-and-of itself may not
be a sufficient basis for termination if the alien has not "voluntarily
availed himself or herself of the protection of the [home] country."*

So in the above examples, there is room to argue that the clients
have not voluntarily availed themselves of the protection of the home
country.* In the case of an alien who returns home to help a relative,
perhaps he entered the country surreptitiously and remained in hiding
during his time there.* Evidence that the alien's journey home was
clandestine might help to counter an attempt to terminate asylum (asylum
may be terminated if DHS shows by a "preponderance of the evidence"
that the alien voluntarily availed himself of the protection his country
-*8 C.F.R. 208.24).

In the example of a political activist who returns to her country to
engage in political activity, she can argue that she did not avail
herself of the protection of her country.* On the contrary, she
challenged her country's government and put herself at risk to do so.

In the case of an alien who returns to his country to work for (or
serve in) the U.S. military, that alien has not availed himself of the
protection of his country.* Rather, he is being protected by the U.S.

In all these examples, the alien is able to argue that he or she has
not "voluntarily availed himself or herself of the protection of the
alien's country of nationality."* The alien in each case could also
appeal to the Attorney General not to terminate asylum as a matter of
discretion.* In these cases, the aliens have returned to their country
for good reasons.* In some cases, the reason for returning might be in
the interest of the U.S. government.* Under such circumstances, the AG
might agree not to terminate asylum as a matter of discretion.

Although asylees who return home can sometimes make decent arguments
against termination, they put themselves at risk of losing their
status.* For this reason, any asylee considering a return trip should
think carefully about the potential consequences.* At a minimum, the
alien should gather as much evidence as possible to show that she has
not voluntarily availed herself of the protection of her country.* She
would also do well to consult an attorney.

Originally posted on the Asylumist:

Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to Facebook Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to Twitter Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to Google Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to StumbleUpon Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to Reddit Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to Digg Submit "When Asylees Return Home" to

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: