ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page


Immigration Daily

Archives

Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board

Resources

Blogs

Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation

Attorney2Attorney

CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network

EB-5

移民日报

About ILW.COM

Connect to us

Make us Homepage

Questions/Comments


SUBSCRIBE

Immigration Daily


Chinese Immig. Daily




The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
Copyright
1995-
ILW.COM,
American
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Matthew Kolken on Deportation And Removal

4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test

Rate this Entry

Yesterday, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals joined the 3rd, 8th, and 11th circuits in rejecting the Attorney General's decision in Matter of Silva-Trevino, 24 I & N Dec. 687, 688-90 (A.G. 2008). See Prudencio v. Holder, Jan. 30, 2012.


The 4th rejected the three-step procedural framework for determining whether a particular conviction is a crime involving moral turpitude because the third step:



allows an immigration judge to rely on documents of questionable veracity as "proof" of an alien's conduct. These documents, such as police reports and warrant applications, often contain little more than unsworn witness statements and initial impressions. Indeed, these materials are designed only to permit a determination of probable cause. Further, because these submissions are generated early in an investigation, they do not account for later events, such as witness recantations,amendments, or corrections. To confer upon such materials the imprimatur of fact, even for the narrow application of removal proceedings involving questions of moral turpitude, accords these documents unwarranted validity.



The 4th declined to sanction the factual approach citing the Supreme Court: "the practical difficulties and potential unfairness of a factual approach are daunting." Shepard, 544 U.S. at 20;Taylor, 495 U.S. at 601.


The Silva-Trevino factual approach permits an Immigration Judge (IJ) to consider otherwise impermissible evidence to determine that a conviction is a crime involving moral turpitude with adverse immigration consequences attaching. Or in other words, if all else fails, throw in the kitchen sink.


This approach enables IJs to impose their own personal and political biases into legal determinations by re-litigating criminal cases in a vacuum, rather than objectively reviewing criminal statutes to determine what immigration consequences, if any, stem from a particular conviction.  The end result, individuals that are not deportable are being deported.


The kitchen sink approach was created because the long established framework for determining whether Silva-Trevino's plea of no contest to "indecency with a child" is a crime of moral turpitude did not end in Silva-Trevino's deportation.  As a result, a new test was created that would procure the desired result.


As we learned in law school: bad facts make bad law. 


Thankfully, we have the Judicial Branch to reign in unlawful interpretations of the law as proscribed by Congress.


Score one for the rule of law.


Correction:


The decision in Matter of Silva-Trevinowas issued by Attorney General Mukasey not Holder.


Commentary regarding Attorney General Holder has been edited, along with the egg on my face.

Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to Facebook Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to Twitter Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to Google Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to StumbleUpon Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to Reddit Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to Digg Submit "4th Circuit joins 3rd, 8th and 11th Rejecting Attorney General's Silva-Trevino CIMT Test" to del.icio.us

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags

Comments

  1. plumbing's Avatar
    I can't relate much, but it's full of ideas. Keep up doing nice posts. You'll surely go far.
  2. allentown workers compensation attorney's Avatar
    i think the rejection is justified
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: