ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Immigration Daily


RSS feed

Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network




Connect to us

Make us Homepage



Immigration Daily


The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
© 1995-
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Angelo Paparelli on Dysfunctional Government

RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship

Rating: 2 votes, 5.00 average.

tusks.jpgLast Friday the Republican National Committee (RNC) passed a resolution opposing a path to citizenship for the 11 million people living among us without immigration status. Viewing these individuals as gate-crashers or overstayers, the resolution claimed that a majority of Americans "oppose any form of amnesty that would propose a pathway to citizenship for illegal aliens." Inexplicably, however, the RNC nonetheless offered this amnesty-lite proposal:

RESOLVED, that the Republican National Committee calls upon the President and Congress to create a new work permit program that will allow foreign nationals who are currently in the country and have not violated any other laws of the U.S. to come forward and register and be allowed to remain and work in the U.S. The work permit will not result in application for citizenship nor any family members entering the U.S. and will require renewal every two years upon proof of continuous employment with no more than two (2) months per two (2) year period unemployed or convicted of a crime.

The resolution provides no explanation for this change of tune.  Rather than espousing the usual shibboleth that immigration amnesty would reward those who flouted the "rule of law" in the U.S., the RNC posits this puzzling twist:

Americans recognize that for many of those seeking entry in our country, the lack of respect for the rule of law in their country of origin has meant economic exploitation and political oppression.

Does this newfound RNC solicitude for the "rule of law in their country of origin" suggest a contorted rationale for amnesty-lite?  The RNC seemingly implies that since these "illegal aliens" (their phrase, not mine) are victims of economic exploitation and political oppression, caused by a lack of respect for the rule of law in their homelands, American immigration law should be amended to go just a tad easier on them here.  It's hard to know for sure, because the resolution doesn't explain the change of heart.

Also befuddling and unexplained is the resolution's support for a "merit system utilizing the newest technology that focuses on the needs of United States employers and matches the economic and cultural attributes that each immigrant possesses to those needs."  Since when do Republicans give a hoot about matching the "cultural attributes" of would-be immigrants and foreign temporary workers to the needs of American employers?  There's a dog whistle in there somewhere, but it's hard to discern.  Are "cultural attributes" a code for "English-only" speakers from abroad?  Again, it's anyone's guess.

One thing is clear, however, and that's self-deportation or "attrition through enforcement" -- the immigration policy of the GOP's last presidential nominee -- is now officially viewed, at least by RNC Chairman, Reince Priebus, as "a horrific comment to make" and "not something that has anything to do with our party."

So, in sum, the RNC's policy seems to be that:

  • Two-year renewable (but non-amnesty) work permits should be granted to "illegal aliens" who broke our immigration laws because they are victims of lawbreaking abroad that led to their economic exploitation and political oppression (but only so long as they stay mostly employed and otherwise remain crime-free);

  • Legal immigration that matches the economic traits of qualified foreign workers and the needs of U.S. employers should be expanded, especially if the workers' "cultural attributes" are similarly aligned; and

  • Self-deportation is horrific and should not be supported as policy by red-blooded Republicans. 

Is this kind of petard-hoisting an illustration of Bobby Jindal's allusion to the "party of stupid" or is it Chris Christie's "focus on winning again"?  Whatever the underlying rationale for the RNC's muddled messaging, the Republican Party needs to develop a more appetizing and inviting policy, for even a majority of its traditional stalwarts, senior citizens, believes it's too extreme on immigration.

Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to Facebook Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to Twitter Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to Google Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to StumbleUpon Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to Reddit Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to Digg Submit "RNC Hoisted on Its Own Immigration Petard in Opposing Path to Citizenship" to

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


  1. Lrosenberg's Avatar
    Can't believe you also used the petard-hoisting image today! Great minds think alike!
  2. renuka's Avatar
    I simply want to tell you that I am new to weblog and definitely liked this blog site. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea.
    Broadcast consultancy
  3. ram15's Avatar
    SCS is focused on providing the most comprehensive, heterogeneous, integrated IT Software solutions to enterprises around the world.
    Citrix Mobility
    SMS Alert Solutions
  4. sewa15's Avatar
    Maharishi Markandeshwar University, Mullana - Ambala, erstwhile known as Maharishi Markandeshwar Education Trust was founded with the objective of social, educational and economic upliftment of society in the year 1993, in the name of Lord Shiva's devotee, "Maharishi Markandeshwar Ji.
    A grade university in north India
    Engineering college in north India
  5. MB22's Avatar
    Engineering as a subject combines mathematics, logic and science to find solutions to our daily life problems. Over the last few decades, engineering as a profession has seen vast expansion.
    B Tech in north india
    Engineering college in Mohali
    Best Mechanical Engineering in Punjab
    BCA college in Punjab
    BBA College in Chandigarh
    Best Campus Placement in Punjab
  6. ray ban aviator's Avatar
    I was planning to make an investment outside my country and would like to gafas ray ban aviator know more on the foreign investment policy of Nigeria.
  7. ray ban aviator's Avatar
    I was planning to make an investment outside my country and would like to <a href="">gafas ray ban aviator</a> know more on the foreign investment policy of Nigeria.
  8. city15's Avatar
    We take pride in being efficient, affordable, and capable of displaying excellence with our product. From home builders to businesses.
    Commercial Concrete Contractor Rochester NY
    Stamped Concrete Rochester NY
    Outdoor Kitchen project Rochester NY
  9. Julia Lukas's Avatar
    How i got my Desired Loan Amount from a Reliable and Trust Loan Company (

    Hello everyone, My name is Julia Lukas, I live in Saxony, Germany. Am here to testify the goodness of God upon my life, how he make me got my loan from Adrian Finance Firm{ ( }. Am a widow with two kids life was hell and uncomfortable for me after the death of my husband. For me to take care of my kids i had to look for a loan to start up a business because nobody was willing to help me and i decided to search for a loan lender online but unfortunately i was scammed Two times from various international loan lenders who claimed to be lenders right here in this forum, i thought their lending was real and i applied but they never gave me loan. I lost hope on loan lenders on internet and was confused and frustrated, until a friend of mine introduce me to Mr Alexander Adrian the managing director of Adrian Finance Firm, who promised to help me with a loan of my desire and he really did as he promised without any form of delay, though I had doubts but just wanted to give it a try and to my greatest surprise the loan was transfer to my bank account . I never thought there are still reliable and genuine loan lenders until i met Mr Alexander Adrian, who really helped me with a loan of €145,000.00Euro and changed my life for the better. I know there are still many loan seekers out there, seek no more and contact the God fearing man for a loan today. Mr Alexander Adrian, his caring and understanding. if you are in need of an urgent loan or want funding for your projects fast and quick, So feel free to contact Adrian Finance Firm via email address : { } OR through company websites: I believe he will help you because he has helped a lot of people across the globe, Thanks.
  10. sony16's Avatar
    Solutions Middle East, works to Envision, Execute and Empower our clients by offerings design, implementation and on-going support services.
    vmware Dubai
    Staff Outsourcing
    Enterprise Data center
    Bulk SMS solutions provider in dubai
    Citrix Load Balancer
    SMS Gateway UAE
  11. sousklein's Avatar
    I would like to thank you for the efforts you've put in writing this web site. I'm hoping the same sous vetement calvin klein high-grade web site post from you in the upcoming also. Actually your creative writing skills has encouraged me to get my own web site now.
Leave Comment Leave Comment
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: