ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page

Immigration Daily


Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board



Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation


CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network




Connect to us

Make us Homepage



The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Immigration Law Blogs on ILW.COM

Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase

Rate this Entry

Judging by the overwhelming lack of interest in my previous posts dealing with Europe's humanitarian crisis caused by the attempts of over a hundred thousand desperate refugees to reach Italy from North Africa, the deaths of thousands of asylum seekers looking for a better life in rich countries are not something that many Americans care about, at least as long as the people concerned are not from Mexico or Central America.

Maybe this is because the story of refugees trying to reach Italy by boat in the Mediterranean by way of Libya is a very old one, at least for the dwindling number of people who still care about the origins of Western culture and civilization, instead of the latest ephemeral i-phone or android gadgets. But there are at least a few people left for whom Virgil's 2,000 year-old opening lines of the Aeneid, which has been and will continue to be around for a good deal longer than the latest apps, still has some meaning.

This is in relation to the tragedy taking place today in what the Romans used to call Mare Nostrum, and which, ironically, was the name of an Italian refugee rescue program whose discontinuance last year has led to even more drownings:

As Virgil wrote:

Arma virumque cano, Troiae qui primus ab oris / Italiam fato profugus Laviniaque venit / littora,

"I sing of arms and the man who first came from the coast of Troy to Italy and the shores of Lavinia, a refugee by fate."

Then, in an immortal line which is meant to describe Aeneas, the legendary ancestor of the two brothers who were said to have founded Rome in 753 B.C., but could also well describe today's refugees coming to Europe from North Africa, Virgil continues:

multum ille et terris iactatus et alto

"He was violently thrown about on land and sea"

Why did this happen?

Virgil explains the cause as:

vi superum, saevae memorem Iunonis ob iram,

"The power of the gods through cruel Juno's never forgotten anger."

But in contrast, to Virgil's attributing the troubles of his hero to divine power, the blame for the tragedies taking place in the Mediterranean is being attributed to more mundane causes. The European right wing, exemplified by Italy's Northern League and France's Front National, led by Marine Le Pen, blames the refugees themselves for not staying where they are.

Many others blame the smugglers, who are taking advantage of the refugees by loading them, sometimes at gunpoint, into rickety boats which are likely to sink and have already caused hundreds, if not thousands, of deaths. Others blame the crisis, with a good deal of justification, on European anti-immigrant feeling and unwillingness to open the door to more refugees.

But, according to a recent Slate article. the cause of Europe's desperate humanitarian crisis is - Libya itself.

See Anne Applebaum: Why So Many Migrants Are Dying in the Mediterranean: The problem isn't poverty or even human trafficking. The problem is Libya.

Applebaum writes:

But now Libya has reappeared in the context of another story: the desperate mass movement of migrants...An oil rich country that should be a sponge for immigrants from Africa and Syria is instead serving as a staging ground for what are often suicidal journeys across the Mediterranean. Libya's human traffickers laugh at the idea that their nation's authorities could stop them."

She continues:

The open, undiscussed truth is that even as the crisis in Libya was unfolding, everyone knew that the Western effort was inadequate and that the European effort in particular was all over the place."

Comparing the Western failure to set up a stable government in Libya with similar failures in Afghanistan and Somalia, she continues:

"Instead of shoring up the central government, international policy seems designed to make it weaker."

Applebaum concludes:

"Before any problem can be solved, it has to be identified. Until Europe's leaders agree that Libya's failed state is the real source of the migration catastrophe, they can't even begin to think about fixing it."

In this sense, events in Libya can be considered to have changed since Virgil wrote his great epic poem. His concern was with the destruction of Libya (Carthage) by the victorious European (Roman) armies during the Punic Wars, two or three centuries before he wrote:

hinc populum late regem bolloque superbum / venturum exidio Libyae;

"A people vast in rule and skilled in war would come to destroy Libya;"

2,000 years later, the problem is not caused by European powers coming to destroy Libya, but by their failure to help it set up a stable government that can offer the refugees safety from ISIS and other factions competing for power in that country, as well as protect them from inhuman exploitation by the traffickers.

Does anyone see a parallel with the Central American children's' refugee crisis which caused such a commotion among anti-immigrant nativists in the US last summer, and may well do again this summer also? In the case of large scale refugee immigration, in America as in Europe, it is always easier to blame the victims of corrupt or failed governments, rather than the circumstances which cause the refugees to flee and look for a safer and better life elsewhere.

Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to Facebook Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to Twitter Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to Google Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to StumbleUpon Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to Reddit Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to Digg Submit "Libya Is Causing Europe's Immigration Crisis, Not Smugglers. By Roger Algase" to

Updated 05-05-2015 at 10:49 AM by ImmigrationLawBlogs

Tags: None Add / Edit Tags


  1. Nolan Rappaport's Avatar
    I agree generally with what Roger is saying. My problem is that I don't see a solution. The most recent UNHCR Statistical Yearbook states that by the end of 2013, armed conflict and persecution had forced 51.2 million individuals to flee from their homes. Presumably that number has risen since then. What would Roger have the international community do? Send troops to all of the countries to stop the armed conflict and keep them there to prevent it from recurring? Or would he have the international community welcome the 50 plus million people displaced by violence and persecution? And if they did, you know the number of people fleeing "armed conflict and persecution" would go way up.
  2. ImmigrationLawBlogs's Avatar
    I agree with Nolan that the international community cannot fix every refugee problem in the world overnight. But I believe we can do more, try harder, and can show more compassion to desperate people without compromising legitimate national interests. In this regard, I will offer another quote from Virgil.

    in Book 1 of the Aeneid, the great poet has the goddess Juno say, referring to the Trojans, Middle Eastern refugees who were trying to reach Italy but wound up (temporarily) in Libya instead:

    genus inimica mihi Tyrrhenum navigat aequor

    ("People of a race that I am hostile toward are now sailing on the Mediterranean.")

    Elsewhere in Book 1, Virgil refers to the Trojans (alleged ancestors of the founders of ancient Rome) as a gens invisum ("despised race") from Juno's point of view.

    2,000 years later, are the attitudes toward Middle Eastern and East African refugees now making a similar journey on the part of influential Europeans such as Marine Le Pen (daughter of her National Front's anti-Semitic and Holocaust denying founder, Jean Marie Le Pen) any different?

    For that matter, are the American politicians who are so anxious to slam our doors against Central American refugee children, at least some of of whom, arguably, have a right to stay in the US under our asylum laws, motivated by anything different from what Juno expresses a good deal more openly and honestly in Virgil's immortal epic?

    Possibly, if more of America's anti-immigrant politicians were educated enough to have actually read Book 1 of the Aeneid (how many have even heard of this poem?), they would be able to recognize the roots of their own mass deportation and "border security first" immigration agendas in Juno's words.

    Roger Algase
    Attorney at Law

    Updated 05-06-2015 at 10:22 AM by ImmigrationLawBlogs
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: