ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page


Immigration Daily

Archives

Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board

Resources

Blogs

Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation

Attorney2Attorney

CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network

EB-5

移民日报

About ILW.COM

Connect to us

Make us Homepage

Questions/Comments


SUBSCRIBE

Immigration Daily


Chinese Immig. Daily




The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
Copyright
© 1995-
ILW.COM,
American
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Matthew Kolken on Deportation And Removal

Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court

Rate this Entry
The following is written by Eliza Klein, a retired United States Federal Immigration Judge who sat on the bench in Miami, Boston and Chicago from 1994 to 2015, in response to the statements of Immigration Judge Jack. H. Weil who claims that toddlers can be taught to represent themselves in Court:

In a deposition taken on October 15, 2015, a witness on behalf of the Department of Justice Executive Office for Immigration Review stated under oath that he had:

"...taught immigration law literally to 3-year-olds and 4-year-olds. It takes a lot of time. It takes a lot of patience. They get it. It's not the most efficient, but it can be done."

Since this testimony was reported by the Washington Post on March 4, 2016, the Department of Justice has responded by saying that the judge who made these remarks was speaking "in his personal capacity" and that judge himself has stated that the remarks do not reflect his actual thinking, and were taken out of context.

Who was the speaker? Assistant Chief Immigration Judge Jack Weil, who was a sitting immigration judge from 1994 until 2009 and who from 2009 to 2013, and again since 2015, has been responsible for training everyone - immigration judges, court administrators, interpreters, judicial law clerks and legal technicians - who make hearings before the immigration courts nationwide possible and whose responsibility it is to ensure that those hearings are fair.

What was the context? A deposition taken by an attorney who has filed a class action lawsuit to obtain legal representation for minors who are placed in removal proceedings. Judge Weil's remarks were taken during what has been reported as a four hour deposition, so perhaps he misspoke. But he confirmed the specific content of his remarks at least twice when the shocked attorney questioning him sought clarification.

The purpose of the remarks was to provide support for the federal government's opposition to the proposition that they should provide attorneys for unaccompanied children in removal proceedings, no matter how young, because providing them "fair hearings" and "due process" is possible, if you just take the time to explain the law to them.

The fact that an intelligent, hard-working judge who had fourteen years of experience on the bench could find himself making such absurd statements to support such a ridiculous proposition is cause for genuine concern over what lengths the Executive Office for Immigration Review will go to abide by the President's political and economic agenda of prioritizing certain cases (people fleeing violence in Central America and Mexico who have recently arrived at our borders seeking protection, as they are legally entitled to do) over others (people whose case may have been pending for years before the immigration courts).

No rational person actually believes a three year old can understand immigration laws of the United States. The law itself is incredibly complex, sometimes contradictory, and in many respects incomprehensible. Judge Jack Weil is not only intelligent and well-versed in conducting immigration hearings, he has raised several children. So what could he have meant? In the context of the deposition, he must have meant that it is possible to provide a fair hearing to a three year old who does not have an adult to speak for her, and who does not have a lawyer. If that is what he meant, it is almost equally ludicrous.

Due process requires both fairness and impartiality. To actually benefit from due process, a person must have a meaningful opportunity to participate in the hearing - in a nutshell, to be heard. There must be an understanding of what information is operative, and an ability to convey that information in an understandable manner.

Immigration judges have a tough job no matter what the circumstances - respondents in removal proceedings are frequently traumatized, unable to understand English, unable to comprehend the legal terminology or evidentiary standards. Judges, attorneys for the government and the respondents all benefit from respondents having counsel. Children, without an adult who is familiar with their life and circumstances, must have an attorney to meaningfully participate in their proceedings and there can be no rational dispute over this.

Indeed, one of the most effective forms of relief for foreign-born children placed in immigration proceedings is Special Immigrant Juvenile Status (SIJS). This status, which requires specific findings from an appropriate state court and a petition approved by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Service, allows a minor to obtain lawful permanent residence. These claims require many continuances from an Immigration Judge to allow the appropriate adjudications. Many experienced attorneys are reluctant to take on these cases because of the overlapping state court and USCIS proceedings - a child acting on their own could not successfully pursue such an application.

The nonsensical remark made by Judge Weil, as a witness to a lawsuit filed to obtain appointed counsel for unaccompanied minors, belies one thing: the fact that the Executive Office for Immigration Review (“EOIR) has lost sight of its mission: "fairly, expeditiously, and uniformly interpreting and administering the Nation's immigration laws.” Perhaps as disturbing, EOIR apparently has abandoned its noble “vision” of “through teamwork and innovation, being the world’s best administrative tribunals, guaranteeing fairness and due process for all.”

The agency's primary concern at this time is to comply with the President's mission of preventing people fleeing Central America from reaching the border of the U.S. and Mexico, by as rapidly as possible removing those that succeed in reaching the border in order to dissuade others from coming. This is not only immoral, it is most likely illegal since our laws allow each such individual to apply for asylum upon arrival. These children are frequently eligible for protection from persecution, but also other forms of relief, such as SIJS or “prosecutorial discretion,”, about which they have no way of knowing. Immigration Judges hearing their cases also have no way of knowing, unless an attorney or other responsible adult is able to investigate their lives. The attorneys representing the Department of Homeland Security cannot reasonably be expected to fulfill that function.

We need an immigration court that is free from the political and economic consideration of the Executive Branch. Immigration Judges need the authority to appoint counsel wherever necessary to ensure a fair opportunity to meaningfully participate in a hearing. When they have jurisdiction over children, they should be able to consider what is in "the best interests" of those children, instead of what is in the best interests of the agency which employs them.

I was an Immigration Judge for over 20 years, and retired in January of 2015. I am sincerely outraged by the extent to which this Administration is willing to go to deny fairness to a group of vulnerable individuals, whose “day in court” they are so happy to expedite.

Eliza Klein received a BA in Anthropology from Kirkland College in 1976, and a J.D. from Northeastern University in 1982. She was admitted to the Bar in Massachusetts in 1983. From 1983 until 1994, she was a solo practitioner concentrating in immigration and criminal matters, but also worked with a non-profit agency which resettled refugees, and with another where she trained and supervised pro-bono attorneys handling asylum cases. She was appointed to the Immigration Court in 1994, and was assigned to Miami. In 1996 she was granted a transfer to the Boston Court and in 2011 to the Chicago Detained Court. She retired from the bench in January 2015, and since then has been working of-counsel with the Gil Law Group, in Aurora, IL

Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to Facebook Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to Twitter Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to Google Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to StumbleUpon Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to Reddit Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to Digg Submit "Former Immigration Judge Responds: No Toddlers Can't Represent Themselves in Court" to del.icio.us

Updated 03-09-2016 at 01:41 PM by MKolken

Comments

  1. Unregistered74's Avatar
    I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your site to check out the new stuff you post.
    192.168.o.1
  2. Herbalist's Avatar
    obat herbal kanker usus stadium 4 Obat Tradisional Alami Kanker usus amazon Plus. Kanker kolorektal yakni sejenis penyakit kanker yang 99,7 % diakibatkan oleh bakteri onkogenik, yang menyerang usus besar. Jenis kanker seperti ini dapat hadir dengan pendarahan pada anus, tetapi ciri-ciri kanker ini tidak terlihat hingga kanker memasuki stadium yang lebih tinggi, yang membuat kanker usus besar fokus pengamatan menggunakan screening usus.

    obat kanker serviks stadium 4 Saya konsumsi sebanyak 3 botol Obat Herbal Alami Kanker Rahim amazon Jus Manggis kurang lebih tiga minggu, saya merasakan ada perubahan yang sangat baik di tubuh saya. Saya juga sudah memeriksakan diri ke dokter dan hasilnya sangat menggembirakan pada saat dinyatakan bahwa kanker saya sudah pulih. Saya minum tiga puluh ml setiap pagi, siang dan malam.. Sampai menit ini saya masih mengonsumsi Obat Herbal Alami Kanker Serviks amazon Jus Manggis.

    obat hepatitis b kronis Apabila didiamkan maka sakit hepatitis akan semakin parah & amat berbahaya bahkan sampai pada kematian. amazon Obat Herbal Penyakit Hepatitis adalah solusi dari semua kendala ini, dengan aromanya yang segar serta memberikan penyembuhan kepada pasien tanpa adanya efek samping berbahaya yang ditimbulkan dari Obat Alami Sakit Hepatitis B ini.
  3. zwoo's Avatar
    outlet zapatos online
    bambas adidas baratas
    ugg boots outlet online
    adidas schoenen
    botas de futbol
    outlet scarpe new balance
    abercrombie deutschland
    new yeezy shoes
    new jordan releases
    toms sale
    mulberry v?skor rea
    nike tn pas cher
    air max pas cher femme
    cheap air max outlet
    cheap uggs
    adidas sneakers
    reebok running shoes
    burberry sac pas cher
    Ugg boots Sale
    nike sportschuhe
    nike air max 90 rea
    louboutin heels
    zapatillas running
    ray ban sale
    Toms Shoes For Women
    scarpe nike
    Nike Store
    scarpe adidas online
    burberry schal
    nike chaussures
    scarpe jordan
    uggs outlet
    moncler jacket sale
    goedkope nike air max
    pandora jewelry store
    asics sko
    fitflops sale uk
    balenciaga borse
    new balance femme
    Adidas schuhe
    michael kors handbags on sale
    nfl store
    michael kors v?ska rea
    Jordan Store
    cheap uggs for women
    Korting sportschoenen
    ugg clearance
    chaussure basket homme
    portafoglio michael kors
    huarache sneakers
    nike damenschuhe
    Nike Air Jordan 11
    ugg boots for women
    nike free
    Air Jordan News
    ray ban sunglasses for men
    Nuove scarpe nike
    fitflop online kopen
    air jordan pas cher homme
    scarpe running new balance
    nike joggesko
    Ray ban sale online
    chaussure Nike femme
    ray ban wayfarer eyeglasses
    Billig Nike
    Nike Online Store
    sac a main michael kors
    Nike Zapatos
    discount ray bans
    zapatillas nike baratas
    nike air schuhe herren
    moncler outlet
    nike jordan shoes
    New Balance Outlet
    chaussure new balance femme
    cheap nike air max
    nike schuhe g?nstig
    zapatilla adidas
    Uomo Hogan
    chaussure Nike homme
    Toms Outlet Online
    Miu Miu bags online
    adidas outlet
    ugg store
    womens nike air max
    abercrombie and fitch store
    toms shoes outlet
    Ray Ban Outlet
    timberland outlet
    adidas shoenen
    Chaussure Nike Pas Cher
    chaussure adidas pas cher
    billige nike sko
    oakley sunglasses clearance
    new balance sportschuhe
    zapatos de futbol nike
    polo ralph lauren pas cher
    adidas store
    coach factory outlet online
    prada outlet
    scarpe nike air max
    nike air
    Cheap Michael Kors
    oakley outlet
    adidas outlet stores online
    nike air max running shoes
    ugg factory outlet
    23 is back
    Billiga Nike Air Max
    scarpe hogan outlet
    Moncler Outlet Online
    michael kors bags outlet
    sandalias birkenstock
    adidas schuhe neu
    longchamp kaufen
    Jordan Schoenen
    cheap ray ban aviators
    scarpe nike running
    chaussures nike pas cher
    Air Jordan Release Date
    uggs for cheap
    ugg boots classic
    nike sneakers
    newest lebron shoes
    vans shoe store
    nike shoes
    Timberland skor
    ugg outlet online
    zwoo 9.6
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: