ILW.COM - the immigration portal Immigration Daily

Home Page


Immigration Daily

Archives

Processing times

Immigration forms

Discussion board

Resources

Blogs

Twitter feed

Immigrant Nation

Attorney2Attorney

CLE Workshops

Immigration books

Advertise on ILW

VIP Network

EB-5

移民日报

About ILW.COM

Connect to us

Make us Homepage

Questions/Comments


SUBSCRIBE

Immigration Daily


Chinese Immig. Daily




The leading
immigration law
publisher - over
50000 pages of
free information!
Copyright
© 1995-
ILW.COM,
American
Immigration LLC.

View RSS Feed

Immigration Law Blogs on ILW.COM

Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?

Rate this Entry


Pew Research Center (PEW) is the gold standard for estimates on the number of undocumented aliens living in the United States. According to PEW, the overall number of undocumented aliens has held steady since 2009. But are the PEW numbers really reliable? What methodology does PEW use to calculate them? Fortunately, PEW explains its methodology on its website. Its estimates are based on a residual estimation methodology that compares a demographic estimate of the number of immigrants lawfully residing in the country with the total number of immigrants as measured by a survey. The difference is assumed to be the number of unauthorized immigrants. This is easier to understand in the form of an equation.


Unauthorized Immigrants (U) = Survey, Total Foreign Born (F) - Estimated Lawful Immigrant Population.


The lawful resident immigrant population is estimated by applying the demographic methods to counts of lawful admissions which are obtained from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Office of Immigration Statistics, with projections to current years, when necessary. Some of the statistics on lawful residents should be very reliable. DHS grants Lawful Permanent Resident status and other forms of lawful status and keeps records of the grants. But it has been estimated that 40% of the undocumented alien population entered as nonimmigrant visitors of various types. This includes aliens who entered as nonimmigrant visitors for pleasure and did not leave when their admission periods expired and other categories of nonimmigrants who violated the terms of their admissions. DHS does not know at any given time how many of the nonimmigrants are still in lawful status.


The foreign born population includes anyone who is not a U.S. citizen at birth, including those who become U.S. citizens through naturalization. PEW estimates of the total foreign born population are based primarily on government census surveys. It currently relies on the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey. This survey includes questions on race, place of birth, citizenship, and when a person came to live in the United States. It is a nationwide survey designed to provide communities with reliable and timely demographic, housing, social, and economic data every year. About 3.5 million housing unit addresses are selected annually. That may sound like a large number, but it is less that 2% of the more than 180 million addresses in the United States. And the United States population in 2015 was estimated to be 321,418,820 people. These addresses cover every county in the nation. The forms are mailed to the selected addresses, not to individuals. For 2015, the American Community Survey selected 3,540,307 addresses in its survey of housing units and had 2,305,707 final interviews. The American Community Survey also selected 206,630 group quarters facilities, such as college dormitories, nursing homes, and prisons; and had 161,865 final interviews at these locations.



PEW also has relied on statistics from the March Supplement to the Current Population Survey. But PEW has dropped that survey because the American Community Survey provides a much larger sample size. In 2014, it produced statistics on 360,000 foreign born individuals, and the March Supplement only provided statistics on 26,000 foreign born individuals. PEW has replaced its March Supplement estimates from 2005 onward with American Community Survey-based estimates.


I have several concerns about PEW’s reliance on the American Community Survey. First, I would be very surprised if many households with an undocumented alien are willing to participate in a government survey of any kind; and this one includes questions about race, place of birth, citizenship, and when a person came to live in the United States. An undocumented alien would not have to be paranoid to be suspicious about why those questions are being asked. I encourage you to read a sample of the form and judge for yourself. Second, I do not understand how PEW can make a reliable estimate of the total foreign born population on the basis of a survey that is sent to such a small portion of our population, particularly in view of the fact that the surveys are spread out across every county in the United States, which makes it unlikely that a reliably representative sampling is taken anywhere. In fact, roughly 35% of the 3,540,307 mailings did not result in a final interview. The surveys at group facilities are even less impressive. Who are these people who would not participate in the survey? How different would the results have been if they had participated?


The problem is not that PEW is using questionable statistics for estimating the lawful immigrant population or that its source of statistics for estimating the foreign born population is unreliable. Math was one of my majors in college. Philosophy was the other. I know that estimates based on such statistics typically are not very reliable. The problem is that PEW’s estimates on the number of undocumented aliens in the United States are being used to make important policy decisions. For instance, the illegal immigration situation is much different if PEW is right that the population of undocumented aliens has remained steady since 2009, than it would be if the population actually has increased from five million to 33 million. Another example is legalization. Estimates for the resources and funding needed for a legalization program are based on PEW’s estimate of how many undocumented aliens there are. The bottom line is that we need to find a more reliable way to estimate the population of undocumented aliens.


Published originally in Huffington Post.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/...=1474689173130


About The Author
Nolan Rappaport
was detailed to the House Judiciary Committee as anExecutive Branch Immigration Law Expert for three years; he subsequentlyserved as the immigration counsel for the Subcommittee on Immigration, BorderSecurity, and Claims for four years. Prior to working on the Judiciary Committee,he wrote decisions for the Board of Immigration Appeals for twenty years. Healso has been a policy advisor for the DHS Office of Information Sharing andCollaboration under a contract with TKC Communications, and he has been inprivate practice as an immigration lawyer at Steptoe & Johnson.






Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to Facebook Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to Twitter Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to Google Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to StumbleUpon Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to Reddit Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to Digg Submit "Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?" to del.icio.us

Updated 09-26-2016 at 03:23 PM by ImmigrationLawBlogs

Comments

  1. Gottfried's Avatar
    Does anyone really know how many undocumented aliens there are?
    About 50+ million undocumented aliens currently live in the US (1 out of 6 persons is unlawfully present in America).

    No need for immigration reform at this time, just grant them renewable work permits and problem solved.
  2. ImmigrationLawBlogs's Avatar
    After Hillary Clinton blew Donald Trump out of the water at the September 26th debate, and exposed him as the utter fraud, liar and bigot that he is now and has been for a long time. at least ever since he began spreading the racist birther lie about President Obama that he now, pathetically, is trying to blame Hillary Clinton for, it might hopefully be less likely that he will make it to the White House to impose his agenda of scapegoating immigrants for all the problems of America on this country.

    Under a Hillary Clinton presidency, America can get back to dealing with its real problems of income inequality and ingrained racism, rather than obsessing over exactly how many unauthorized immigrants (or "illegal aliens") there might be in America at any given moment.

    This issue reminds me of the medieval debates over how many angels (or devils) could stand on the head of a pin. I am sure that PEW Research, if it had been around in the Middle Ages, would have had less than totally precise or accurate figures on that point too.

    Roger Algase
    Atorney at Law
    Updated 09-28-2016 at 03:28 AM by ImmigrationLawBlogs
  3. ImmigrationLawBlogs's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by ImmigrationLawBlogs
    After Hillary Clinton blew Donald Trump out of the water at the September 26th debate, and exposed him as the utter fraud, liar and bigot that he is ....

    Under a Hillary Clinton presidency, America can get back to dealing with its real problems of income inequality and ingrained racism, rather than obsessing over exactly how many unauthorized immigrants (or "illegal aliens") there might be in America at any given moment.

    This issue reminds me of the medieval debates over how many angels (or devils) could stand on the head of a pin. I am sure that PEW Research, if it had been around in the Middle Ages, would have had less than totally precise or accurate figures on that point too.

    Roger Algase
    Atorney at Law
    Roger,
    You keep asking me for examples of ad hominem attacks and character assassinations. Here's one, "exposed him as the utter fraud, liar and bigot that he is"

    You think income inequality and ingrained racism are the real problems? What about the problems Trump mentioned during the debate, e.g. a national debt of approximately 20 trillion dollars; violent crime in our inner cities; American businesses moving their operations to foreign countries to avoid American taxes and use cheap foreign labor instead of American workers; and so on? Those aren't important too?

    As for how many angels can dance on the head of a pin, were important policy decisions being based on that estimate too?

    Without a reliable estimate on the undocumented population, we have no way of determining how big of a problem illegal immigration has become, which is a way to evaluate how effective enforcement practices are.

    Also, what about the requirement that the Congressional Budget Office has to provide formal, written estimates of the cost of virtually every bill approved by Congressional committees to show how the bill would affect spending or revenues over the next 5 or 10 years, depending on the type of spending involved. How will that be done for a legalization program without a reliable estimate on the number of undocumented aliens?

    And the republicans will insist on meaningful background investigations, which would have to include interviews in person. How will anyone know whether the cost and resources of processing legalization applications is feasible without a reliable estimate of the undocumented population? What if there are 40 million undocumented aliens who could apply for legalization? Is it possible to interview and do effective background investigations on 40 million people? I suspect that many of them would die of old age while waiting for a decision on their applications. If the number is prohibitive, hard choices would have to be made to reduce the number of applicants. The time to make those choices is before the applications come pouring in, not after.

    Nolan Rappaport
    Updated 09-28-2016 at 02:59 PM by ImmigrationLawBlogs
  4. ImmigrationLawBlogs's Avatar
    Do you mean that Donald Trump somehow is not a fraud, a liar and a bigot (as well as a potential dictator who has little or no respect for our Constitution and rule of law?)? That would be a difficult argument to maintain.

    Certainly, Huffington Post, a publication that you write for, would never make that argument.

    Roger Algase
    Attorney at Law
Put Free Immigration Law Headlines On Your Website

Immigration Daily: the news source for legal professionals. Free! Join 35000+ readers Enter your email address here: